PO Box 61051

Durham, NC 27715-1051

Phone:  (919) 416-5077   

Fax:  (919) 286-3985

ncwarn@ncwarn.org   www.ncwarn.org

Waste Awareness and Reduction Network

               NC WARN

 

 

NEWS RELEASE                                           Contact:  Jim Warren or Pete MacDowell, NC WARN

January 5, 2006                                                               919-416-5077

           

Progress Admits Security Problems at Harris N-Plant

 

More Guards Confirm Vulnerabilities, Retaliation; Federal Investigators Arrive

 

DURHAM, NC – Two more allegations of security failures at the Shearon Harris nuclear plant have been confirmed – this time by plant owner Progress Energy itself.  At least five of the serious charges made by plant whistleblowers are now verified, NC WARN said today.  The watchdog group also said a guard at another Securitas-protected nuclear plant contacted NC WARN this week, describing similar patterns of lax security and severe reprisals against guards who alerted superiors and regulators to security failings.

 

As reported in today’s Raleigh News & Observer, Progress Energy has confirmed that a Harris guard reported being fired on while on patrol in August, putting the plant on heightened alert.  The company spoke further about a number of security doors found unsecured for an unknown time period.  In a letter today to Progress CEO Robert McGehee, NC WARN pointed to discrepancies in the company’s public statements and urged him to personally order full cooperation with federal and state investigators, including determining how many doors were left unsecured, and for how long.  Guards say the problems have apparently persisted for years; federal law requires an unsecured door to be reported within one hour, and a guard posted until its repair.

 

Since NC WARN and the Union of Concerned Scientists filed a December 13th complaint based on 15 hours of interviews with a Harris guard, other guards have contacted the groups and The Independent Weekly.  They confirmed the allegations of a climate of lax security and reprisals against guards reporting vulnerabilities such as failing doors to vital areas, inoperable plant gates, falsified security records and forced cheating on certification exams.  The guards say plant managers interfere with guards inspecting vehicles at checkpoints, and force guards to work with severe injuries that impair their ability to defend against potential intruders.

 

“It’s hard to tell how widespread these failures go,” said NC WARN’s Jim Warren, who conducted the interviews with the initial whistleblower.  “The experiences of a single courageous guard are being verified by others, the records and now by Progress Energy itself.”

 

Senior NRC officials told NC WARN and Union of Concerned Scientists this week that on-site inspectors have now “verified” about half of Harris’ security doors, but could not discuss how many might have been unsecured.  The officials indicated they are stepping up their involvement by sending a team of security investigators to Harris next week to confidentially interview guards and audit plant records.  The NRC’s Inspector General has begun its own investigation because guards say NRC allowed their complaints of security failings to go uncorrected.  The watchdog groups say NC Attorney General Roy Cooper is responsible for charges involving criminal activity and for contractor Securitas and its guards.

 

In a letter today to Progress CEO Robert McGehee, NC WARN and UCS detailed discrepancies in Progress’ public statements about malfunctioning doors, and noted that neither the company nor NRC have confirmed that doors have been fixed or how long they were unsecured.  They pointed out that felony charges could ensue if it is confirmed that guards were ordered not to check doors – some to Vital Areas – or report their inoperability.

 

“In the absence of any contradictory evidence, it is prudent to assume the other serious

allegations from your plant guards are also accurate,” NC WARN told McGehee in the letter.      

 

Pete MacDowell of NC WARN said today that the Securitas guard from another plant is a disturbing development.  “We could hope Harris is the only plant with serious security shortcoming, but it would be counter-intuitive to do so.”   He said the other plant’s guard expressed the same concern as those from Harris –that the plants are poorly protected despite the recent reiteration by the 9/11 panel that nuclear plants are top terrorist targets and that the government has failed to secure them even if current regulations were adhered to.

 

MacDowell said the public has a right to know about the system failings at Harris:  “We’re urging Mr. McGehee and Attorney General Cooper not to let their people hide behind bogus claims of ‘security’ to obscure  Shearon Harris’ problems,” he said.  “There is no legitimate reason the problems that have so far surfaced should be considered ‘security sensitive’ unless they have not been corrected.”

 

##

 

 

Letter to CEO McGehee: http://www.ncwarn.org/Campaigns/NuclearWatchdog/Ltr%20to%20R%20McGehee%20Jan%205.pdf